Learn from Phoenix Town’s lesson

By Tian Ye and Wang Jiaquan

The controversy towards a Chinese tourism county’s collection of entry fees has illustrated how bad the result can become when authorities use arbitrary measures to seek economic gains at the cost of public interests.

From April 17, tourists were required to pay 148 yuan (23.9 U.S. dollars) upon entry into Fenghuang (Chinese equivalent to Phoenix), a county in Hunan Province, known for its well-preserved architecture dating back to its founding more than 300 years ago. Part of the ticket revenue goes to the local government.

The ticket policy was not welcomed by locals, who own businesses that range from ferries to home inns in the county. They believe it will deter tourists, who spend money in the town.

In response to public queries, local officials in Fenghuang proposed local businesses merge and promised to offer job training for those whose trade might be affected, leading to suspicions that the local government wanted to monopolize businesses by setting rules.

The local government in Fenghuang is apparently a loser though the new policy proved a cash cow. Nearly 2.3 million yuan worth of tickets were sold in four days after the new policy, despite only about 200 independent travelers paying their way in.

The money was made at a heavy cost: tax was down as a result of less business in the town and public anger increased.

The decision makers in Fenghuang must not have imagined the entry fee policy would trigger such a backlash though they may have fairly expected some opposition.

The controversy has led to more media coverage and online discussions as people prepare to embrace the coming May Day holiday.

Soon after the policy was introduced, local retailers protested, despite order being restored shortly after. Potential tourists said they would make a detour.

The credibility of the government of Fengshuang was further undermined after tens of thousands of Chinese Internet users started to criticize the move. They accused local government of eying fast money by sacrificing public interests and disrupting market order by abusing its administrative power.

The ticket policy, to some extent, also showed how central policies can sometimes be awfully carried out by officials at grassroots level.

The central leadership has sought to establish an administration that is more streamlined and ruled by law. The ticket policy, which was introduced without ample public debate and hearing, has run counter to the trend of China’s current reform.

At a time when China is undergoing tremendous change, officials should be more conscious of the rights of the public and the role of the government before any decisions are made.



  1. nike zoom pegasus 33 womens black gold…

    nike air yeezy 2 custom diddysns x reebok twilight zone pump punschrulle releasingair jordan after game orange goldnike zoom structure 20 womens white gold…

  2. nike roshe run floral purple pink…

    womens nike air max thea blue greenair jordan retro 10 steelnike lebron xiii low bluenike air max cage ts orange white…

  3. wss countdown to kickoff featured…

    concepts new balance 998 grand tourerboys nike shoes clearancenike air max plus iii tn nike air max plus 3 tn tuned air black leather 2007 photo 1nike kd 8 bhm black multi color for sale…

  4. nike cortez classic white red…

    nike lebron 12 xii color black challenge red total orange black style 685181 010. price 160.00pink supercolor adidasadidas zx 630 grey redmens nike air max 87 sb yellow orange…

  5. nike air foamposite one varsity red another look…

    adidas originals jabbar hi the blueprintair jordan i 1 bannedlebron 12 elite rose goldall white timberlands women…

  6. Beberapa poin yg benar-benar menarik yang pernah anda ctat banyak saya sampaikan, hanya apa yg saya cari: D.Takee a look at my webpage: bascovazko

  7. Finee waү of explaining, and nice post tο obtaіn informatіon aboᥙt
    my presentation subject matter, ᴡhich i am ɡoing to present in college.

    Hеre is my webpage cara memutihkan muka

  8. Helⅼo there! I cоuld have sworn Ӏ’ve visitd tһis web site before but afteг goіng tһrough some
    of the articles I realized it’ѕ neᴡ tо me. Ⲛonetheless, I’m definiitely pleased Ι stumblesd upon it and Ӏ’ll Ьe book-marking іt annd
    checking bɑck regularly!

    My website – daftar ahli mary kay

  9. Tһanks for evеry other wonderful post. The place eⅼse mаy аnyone get that typpe
    of info іn suhh аn ideal manner off writing?
    І haave a presentation subsequent ԝeek, and Ι am аt the search f᧐r
    sᥙch information.

    Feel free to surf too my web blog: testimoni set serum melacep mary kay

  10. ilmu yang berguna gan.. terima kasih semoga sukses konsisten mohon pencerahan agar website ane mamppu naik ranking gan

    Also visit my web blog – wallpaper dinding 3d

  11. makasih atas ceritanya gan, amat menarik dan semoga
    ini bakal bermanfaat gan…

    Sttop by my wweb blog :: wallpaper dinding rumah

  12. Rataj wrote:

    Hey there by Florida! I’m bored at the job so i made a decision to view your web site in the iphone 3gs throughout lunch separate. I enjoy the information a person offer below as well as can’t hang on to be able to take a peek once i go back home. I’m astonished in exactly how rapidly your website crammed about our cellphone.. I’m not utilizing , only 3G. At any rate, great blog site!

  13. I studied in a couple of schools for appearing.

  14. Thank you for the auspicious writeup. Іt in fact
    ᴡas a amusement acccount іt. Loоk advanced to farr added agreeable frߋm you!
    However, how couⅼd we communicate?

    Feell free tօ visit mʏ web blog :: cara menghilangkan parut di muka

Leave a Reply